“Toes”, off indie rock band Glass Animals’ 2014 debut album ‘ZABA’, is a song based on the 1896 science fiction novel “The Island of Doctor Moreau”.
The novel is about a disturbed ‘scientist’, the island he owns, and the men he’s–literally–turned into inhuman beasts that live there.
The first part of the chorus goes as follows:
I’m a man, I’m a twisted fool
My hands are twisted too
Five fingers to black hooves
The lyrics are written in stanza form, most often used in poetry. The speaker refers to himself as a man, but then refers to himself as a ‘twisted fool’. Not only does this convey that the speaker is mentally disturbed in some way, perhaps referencing the state of the owner of the island, but also suggests that the speaker is being mutilated in some way or form, as in the next lines, he states that his hands are twisting into hooves.
The last line is also deliberately left ambiguous–‘five fingers to black hooves’ could be depicting how his hands are twisting into hooves, but it could be also be interpreted as ‘five fingers, two black hooves’, suggesting that it’s his lower half that is being mutilated. It conveys a sense of confusion, reinforcing that even the speaker is unclear about what’s happening to him. It could also be referencing the common depiction of the devil in the media, as a half man half goat creature, that the speaker sees himself as something twisted and evil. Either way, the lyrics clearly aren’t surface level.
I’m a man, don’t spin me a lie
Got toes and I can smile
I’m crooked but upright
The second half of the chorus depicts the speaker desperately clinging onto any sense of humanity he has left. He takes on a more aggressive tone, telling the audience not to ‘spin him a lie’. He’s clinging to the fact that he still has toes, that he is still human, despite the fact that his body has been twisted beyond comprehension upon his stay at the island. He still has toes, despite the fact that his hands are twisted and hooved, and he can still smile, despite the fact that he is now a monster. He is crooked, but still upright.
Overall, this song has a lot of intriguing lines that are definitely poetry. It’s a really fascinating story, and I could even go as far as to say it would be impossible to argue that it is not poetry. This has been one of my favorite tunes since I was really little, and I can’t recommend it enough if you find this post at least somewhat interesting.